Unfortunaltey we have someone in our community who seems to be dedicated to promoting the notion that our beloved brothers in prisons are actually justly imprisoned. Most intereting, is his statement with regards to Shaykh Ali Al-Timimi. He says “as muslims living in the west, we should stand on the side of justice, even if its against our own mothers.” He advocates that Shaykh Ali Al-Timimi is guilty and that he should in fact be imprisoned by the US authroties, who are mainly monkey jews and the sons of pigs. He means to turn his back on our beloved brothers in prison, who are suffering because of us, because we are not fulfilling the obligations to free the prisoners and wage jihad against the ape jews who should rub their faces in the stool of donkeys. More drastic and very much expected, are the unjust sunniforum moderators who allow people to say such batil statements and deviant statements in public which they will never delete. But, they will delete any posts supporting our brothers in prisons and any our brothers in Palestine, Iraq and Afghanistan. But at the same time, they delete posts that call Sharon (the son of monkey) a “Zionists” with the ridiculous claim that it lacks “adab”. Such are the unjust moderators of sunniforum. I am always so surprised that these people who are brainwashed by the ideologies of some people, never actually tell us what we SHOULD do, but they are very quick to point out what we SHOULDN’T do. It is like picking up a prayer fiqh book, and it only lists things that are haram to do in prayer, but will never actually show you how to actually pray. Here I will inshaAllah mention a few fatawa by our Beloved Muftis in regards to our muslim obligation towards our beloved brothers in prisons, and surprisingly, one of them was translated on sunniforum.
__________________________________________________________________________________
Question: Asalamu alaykum shaykh. As you are aware many of our Muslim brothers are currently imprisoned in Guantanomo Bay. What is the duty of the rest of the Muslims towards these imprisoned brothers? JazakAllah khair.
Wasalam.
Answer: Respected Brother in Islam,
Assalamu Alaykum Wa Rahmatullaahi Wa Barakatuhu,
When Muslims are imprisoned unjustly, as is the case in Guantanamo, it is the Waajib duty of all the Muslims of the world to do whatever is in their capacity to free these oppressed brothers.
Together with our efforts, it is our duty to continuously make du'aa for them.
And Allah Knows Best.
Was Salaam.
Mufti E. Desai
Fatwa Dept.
Jamiatul Ulama (KZN)
Council of Muslim Theologians.
_____________________________________________________________________________________
28/01/2005
S No.: =====769
Fatwa No: ==27937
Date: ======26/12/2004
Subject: The Right of the Imprisoned
Question: Respected Mufti sahib, as you know the fall of the Islamic Emirate of Afghanistan has resulted in the imprisonment of a large number of our Muslim brothers in the jails of the Disbelievers and the Heretics, where they are being treated inhumanely. What is the right of these Muslim brothers upon us? Please elucidate, may God reward you.
Answer: Praise be to God and Salutations upon his Prophet
In such a situation it is incumbent upon the rest of the Muslims that they impress upon the Muslim rulers the need to make efforts for the release of these oppressed Muslim brothers and they should also make personal efforts for this and if there arises a need for monetary help in this regard, they should not abstain from providing it. Nonetheless prayer should be made that they may be granted patience in the face of tribulation, steadfastness upon the religion of Islam and release from prison. And God is the Greater Knower of what is right.
The Servant Qamar uz Zaman, May God grant him forgiveness.
Dar ul Ifta - Jamia Binoria Karachi
29th DhiQa'dah 1425 H
{Attestation of Mufti Sayfullah Jameel}
"The Answer is correct."
The Servant Sayfullah Jameel
Dar ul Ifta - Jamia Binoria Karachi
29 -11 -1425 H
{Attestation of Mufti Abdullah Shaukat - Head of Ifta}
"The Answer is correct."
Abdullah Shaukat
Dar ul Ifta - Jamia Binoria Karachi
6th DhulHijjah 1425 H
_____________________________________________________________________________________
Question: Bismillahi Rahman Rahim
InshAllah you and you families are doing well. This question
is in regards to Guantanamo Bay prisoners and other Muslim
prisoners all over the world. I would appreciate it if you
given me very detailed answers with stories of the Sahaba if
at all possible.
1.) What is our duty to these prisoners? I have heard on
other fataawa that it is obligatory for every Muslim to do
everything he can. Please explain to me if this is correct. I
need a juristic understanding of why it is obligatory or not.
2.) What is the Islamic ruling on torturing other Muslims?
Also, what is the Islamic ruling on non-Muslims torturing
Muslim brothers in prison? At the time of the Prophet, peace
and blessings be upon him, what was the reaction of the
Prophet, peace and blessinf be upon him, about hearing the
Sahaba getting tortured? When non-muslims are torturing
muslims, what are the obligations of other muslims?
Jazakullahu Kharian for spending time and reading my
question. I would appreciate it if you post this on the
website so that way many people can see and I would also have
a reference. May Allah Subhana Wa Tala Bless you and your work.
Ma salam
Answer:Respected Brother/Sister-in-Islam
Assalaamu Alaykum Wa Rahmatullaahi Wa Barakaatuh
Islamic governments around the world should be urged to assist in the light
of international laws on a governmental level in order to free Muslim
prisoners who are imprisoned without a just cause. If nothing is done on a
governmental level, then as citizens, we should only make Du'aa and do
nothing else. The citizens should protest regarding this in a legal way in
order to force their Islamic governments to carry out this task. If in order
to free Muslim prisoners, funds are required, then these funds should be
generously donated.
The Islamic government is responsible to assist in freeing Muslim prisoners
who are being tortured around the world. Citizens should urge the government
in a legal way in order to free tortured Muslims around the world. It is not
permissible for Muslims to torture prisoners. In the time of Nabi (SAW) some
Muslims were being tortured. This was in such a time when He (SAW) could not
fight. Nabi (SAW) persevered during this time. We should also be patient and
make Du'aa for our brothers.
and Allah Ta'ala Knows Best
Mufti Muhammad Ashraf
DARUL IFTA - JAMEAH MAHMOODIYAH, SPRINGS
JOINT PROJECT WITH DARUL IFTA, MADRASAH IN'AAMIYYAH, CAMPERDOWN